(usagi-users 03509) Re: RCODE =3 (Name Error) + DNS

[JINMEI Tatuya / 神明達哉 <jinmei@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

>>>>> On Thu, 6 Oct 2005 10:39:19 +0530, 
>>>>> Sanjib Das <Sanjib.Das@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> said:

> that i have tested like, i have my own domain "ipv6.domain."
> No within this i have one of my host as "myhost.ipv6.domain."
> but while querying i do it like this

> dig host.ipv6.domain.  AAAA

> getting the response with RCODE = 3. 
> where i got the doubt is like, if we make mistake in the domain name 
> itself
> like, instead of ipv6.domain say i typed ip.domain. In this case also 
> should i get 
> the response with RCODE = 3, if my server is the authritative for this 
> zone 
> (i configured it as root server for my domain).
> In this case i donot get the response with RCODE = 3.

I suspect dig actually asked the real root servers in the Internet.
Make sure that it directly asks your own (internal?) root server which
manages the imaginary "ipv6.domain".

> One thing more, in BIND9, this RCODE = 3 they have represented as NXDOMAIN
> not as Name Error. I donno what this NXDOMAIN really means, whereas it got 
> the
> same RCODE (3) value like Name Error (As per RFC 4074) 

NXDOMAIN is a BIND specific terminology which represents RCODE 3 and
stands for non existent domain.  Since an RFC should be "neutral", it
uses the standard keyword.

BTW: RFC4074 is not a very appropriate reference in this context.  You
might rather want to refer to more basic reference to DNS, such as
RFC1034 and/or RFC1035.

					JINMEI, Tatuya
					Communication Platform Lab.
					Corporate R&D Center, Toshiba Corp.
					jinmei@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx